Aggregate production functions and other neoclassical fairy tales
7 Apr, 2014 at 15:34 | Posted in Economics | 4 CommentsWhen one works – as one must at an aggregate level – with quantities measured in value terms, the appearance of a well-behaved aggregate production function tells one nothing at all about whether there really is one. Such an appearance stems from the accounting identity that relates the value of outputs to the value of inputs – nothing more.
All these facts should be well known. They are not, or, if they are, their implications are simply ignored by macroeconomists who go on treating the aggregate production function as the most fundamental construct of neoclassical macroeconomics …
The consequences of the non-existence of aggregate production functions have been too long overlooked. I am reminded of the story that, during World War II, a sign in an airplane manufacturing plant read: “The laws of aerodynamics tell us that the bumblebee cannot fly. But the bumblebee does fly, and, what is more, it makes a little honey each day.” I don’t know about bumblebees, but any honey supposedly made by aggregate production functions may well be bad for one’s health.
Attempts to explain the impossibility of using aggregate production functions in practice are often met with great hostility, even outright anger. To that I say … that the moral is: “Don’t interfere with fairytales if you want to live happily ever after.”
4 Comments
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
Blog at WordPress.com.
Entries and Comments feeds.
All these facts should be well known. They are not, or, if they are, their implications are simply ignored by macroeconomists who go on treating the aggregate production function as the most fundamental construct of neoclassical macroeconomics …







[…] Aggregate production functions and other neoclassical fairy tales Lars P. Syll […]
Pingback by Links 4/8/14 | naked capitalism— 8 Apr, 2014 #
Excellent , Lars !
Comment by Marko— 8 Apr, 2014 #
A useful brief summary of some of the issues (intelligible to the non-economist) is available in Stefan Bergheim’s Long-Run Growth Forecasting (2008), Chap. 2.6.
Comment by KM— 7 Apr, 2014 #
Of course, disaggregate production functions are also fairy tales: output is not a function of inputs, and “maximum” output cannot be defined in an uncertain world. But, oh well.
Comment by Bruce Wilder— 7 Apr, 2014 #